Does Expungement Show on an FBI Background Check?
State expungement does not always clear your FBI record. Here is how the FBI rap sheet works and what you can do about it.
You got your expungement. The court signed the order. Your state criminal history was updated. You applied for a federal job, a security clearance, or a professional license — and the background check came back showing the conviction you thought was gone.
What happened?
The short answer: state expungement clears your state record. It does not automatically clear your federal record. The FBI maintains its own criminal history database, and updating it after a state expungement depends on a chain of communication between state agencies and the FBI that does not always work the way it should.
This article explains how the FBI background check system actually works, why expunged records sometimes still appear, and what you can do about it.
This is not legal advice.
This guide explains how the law works in general terms. Whether you qualify depends on your specific record, and a judge makes the final call. If your situation is complicated — multiple convictions, charges in multiple states, or a previous denial — consulting a lawyer who handles expungement is worth the cost of a consultation.
How the FBI Criminal History Database Works
The FBI maintains a criminal history database through its Criminal Justice Information Services (CJIS) Division, headquartered in Clarksburg, West Virginia. This database — often called the “rap sheet” or formally the Identity History Summary — is built from fingerprint submissions sent by state and local law enforcement agencies across the country.
When you are arrested, your fingerprints are taken and submitted to both your state criminal records repository and the FBI. The FBI creates a record tied to your fingerprints. Every subsequent arrest, charge, and disposition that a state reports to the FBI gets added to this record.
The key word is “reports.” The FBI does not independently track what happens in state courts. It relies entirely on states to send updates. When a state court expunges your record, the state identification bureau is supposed to notify the FBI, which then updates or removes the entry. But “supposed to” and “actually does” are two different things.
- State notification delay — after a court grants expungement, the state identification bureau must process the order and transmit the update to the FBI. This can take 30 to 120 days, and some states have significant backlogs.
- State never notified the FBI — some states are inconsistent about sending expungement notifications to the FBI. The court updates the state record, but the FBI never receives the update.
- FBI processing lag — even after the FBI receives notification, updating the record takes additional time. The FBI processes millions of records and updates are not instantaneous.
- Arrest record vs. conviction record — the FBI tracks arrests separately from convictions. A state may expunge the conviction but the underlying arrest record may still appear on the FBI report.
- Multiple state entries — if you have records in multiple states, each state must independently notify the FBI. One state updating does not affect entries from another state.
The system relies on each link in the chain — court to state bureau to FBI — working correctly. Breakdowns at any point leave the FBI record unchanged.
FBI Background Check vs. Standard Background Check
This distinction is critically important and often misunderstood: the background check most employers and landlords run is not an FBI background check.
Most private employers use commercial background check companies — Checkr, Sterling, HireRight, First Advantage, and others. These companies build their reports from state court records, county records, and their own databases. They do not have access to the FBI database. The FBI database is available only to authorized agencies — law enforcement, certain government employers, and entities authorized by federal law to request fingerprint-based checks.
This means that for the vast majority of job applications, apartment applications, and professional licensing situations, the FBI record is irrelevant. Your state expungement clears the state record, and the commercial background check companies pull from the state record. The FBI issue only arises in specific contexts.
- 1.Federal employment — all positions within federal agencies require an FBI background check.
- 2.Security clearances — anyone applying for a security clearance (Confidential, Secret, Top Secret) undergoes an FBI check as part of the investigation.
- 3.Military enlistment — the Department of Defense runs FBI checks on all recruits.
- 4.Immigration — USCIS runs FBI checks as part of visa, green card, and naturalization applications.
- 5.Law enforcement employment — state and local police agencies often require an FBI check in addition to a state check.
- 6.Certain professional licenses — healthcare, childcare, banking, and some education positions require FBI checks depending on the state.
- 7.Firearms purchases — the National Instant Criminal Background Check System (NICS) used for gun purchases draws from FBI data.
- 8.TSA PreCheck and Global Entry — the application process includes an FBI fingerprint check.
If you are applying for a standard private-sector job or renting an apartment, the employer or landlord is almost certainly not running an FBI check. They are using a commercial background check company that pulls from state records — which your expungement has already addressed.
How to Request Your FBI Record
You have the right to request your own FBI Identity History Summary. This is the single most important step if you are concerned about what the FBI has on file. You cannot challenge what you have not seen.
The process costs $18 and requires your fingerprints. You can submit electronically through an FBI-approved channeler (faster — typically 2 to 4 weeks) or by mail using a fingerprint card (slower — 12 to 16 weeks). The FBI provides a list of approved electronic channelers on its website at fbi.gov.
When you receive your Identity History Summary, it will list every arrest and disposition that states have reported to the FBI over your lifetime. Review it carefully against your actual court records.
How to Challenge an Inaccurate FBI Record
If your FBI record shows a conviction that was expunged by a state court, you have the right to challenge it. The process requires going through your state identification bureau first, then escalating to the FBI if necessary.
Steps to correct your FBI criminal history record
- 1
Request your FBI Identity History Summary
2–4 weeks for electronic, 12–16 weeks by mail$18.00Submit a request through the FBI's Identity History Summary Check service. You will need to provide your fingerprints — either electronically through an approved channeler or via a paper fingerprint card (FD-258) submitted by mail. The FBI uses fingerprints, not names, to match records.
The electronic option through an approved FBI channeler is significantly faster. The FBI maintains a list of approved channelers on its website.
- 2
Review the report for accuracy
1–2 daysNoneWhen you receive your Identity History Summary, review every entry. Check that arrests and convictions are listed accurately. Look for entries that should have been removed due to expungement, sealing, or dismissal. Note any errors — wrong charges, incorrect dispositions, entries from cases that were not yours.
Compare each entry against your actual court records. If a state expungement was granted but the FBI record still shows the conviction, that is the specific discrepancy you will challenge.
- 3
Contact your state identification bureau
30–90 daysNoneThe FBI does not accept challenges about state-level records directly. You must go through your state's identification bureau — typically the State Police or Department of Justice criminal records division. Contact them with a copy of your expungement order and request that they update the record submitted to the FBI.
Send your request by certified mail with return receipt. Include a copy of the signed court order and your FBI Identity History Summary showing the inaccurate entry.
- 4
Submit a challenge to the FBI if the state does not act
30–90 days for FBI responseNoneIf the state identification bureau does not update the record within a reasonable time, or if the FBI record is inaccurate for other reasons, you can submit a challenge directly to the FBI Criminal Justice Information Services (CJIS) Division. Include your Identity History Summary, the specific entries you are challenging, and supporting documentation.
The FBI will contact the state to verify the information. Having already made your request to the state bureau strengthens your position.
What Expungement Cannot Do at the Federal Level
There are limits to what state expungement accomplishes in the federal system, and you deserve a straight answer about them.
- Immigration proceedings — federal immigration law (INA) has its own framework for evaluating criminal history. A state expungement does not eliminate a conviction for immigration purposes. USCIS may still consider an expunged conviction when evaluating visa or naturalization applications.
- Security clearances — applicants for security clearances must disclose all criminal history, including expunged records, on the SF-86 form. Failure to disclose is itself grounds for denial.
- Federal firearms law — state expungement may not restore federal firearms rights if the underlying conviction was a felony or a domestic violence misdemeanor. Federal law has its own disqualifiers.
- Federal criminal history database — even after the FBI updates your record to reflect the expungement, the record of the original entry may still exist in federal databases in a modified form (e.g., marked as "expunged").
- Some professional licensing — certain federally regulated licenses (banking, securities, aviation) may still consider expunged convictions.
These limitations affect a specific subset of situations. For the vast majority of everyday purposes — private employment, housing, state professional licenses — a state expungement is fully effective.
The Practical Takeaway
For most people, the FBI background check issue is far less significant than it feels. The anxiety about it is real, but the actual impact is narrow. Here is the practical breakdown:
If you are applying for private-sector jobs, the employer is not running an FBI check. They are using a commercial background check company. Your state expungement handles this.
If you are applying for apartments, the landlord is using a tenant screening service. Your state expungement handles this.
If you are applying for state professional licenses, the licensing board is checking your state criminal history. Your state expungement handles this in most cases.
The FBI issue matters primarily for federal employment, military service, immigration, security clearances, and certain federally regulated professions. If those are relevant to you, request your FBI Identity History Summary and follow the challenge process. If they are not relevant to you, focus on making sure private background check companies have updated their records — which is where Record Sweep comes in.
Ready to file? We handle the paperwork.
Pre-filled court forms, step-by-step checklist, text reminders at every milestone. $149.